How we’re paying off over $500,000 of student loan debt

While a majority of students today graduate with some level of student loan debt, we happened to be well above the normal distribution with a sum of over $500,000 between the two of us following an eight year stretch from 2005 to 2013 in which my wife and I financed the majority of our educations. The bulk of this balance coming in the later years while my wife pursued a degree in dentistry.

While it came at a significant cost, we don’t curse or regret our debt.

Of course, all things being equal, we’d rather it not be hanging over our heads and we’re anxious for the day we put it behind us, but we chose this path and we knew what we were signing up for from the beginning.

Our debt is a temporary inconvenience and nothing more.

In exchange for the inconvenience, we each got something great. We wouldn’t have our current careers without financing our educations and we don’t sit around regretting the fact that we invested in ourselves.

My wife and I share our finances 100%. There’s no ‘my money’ or ‘her money’. We have common and shared goals and that has led us to having shared finances from the start. We understand that this doesn’t work for everyone, but it’s what works for us. Using this same logic, the loans we have aren’t separated either.

So how are we going about paying off $500,000+ of student loans? What follows are five steps we took after graduating to head down the path of debt reduction.

1) Getting organized

With many debts acquired over the years, we started by building a spreadsheet containing a list of all loans and lenders. This step was fairly easy as information for all of our federal loans was accessible at the National Student Loan Data System student access site at nslds.ed.gov.

2) Set up minimum payments for all loans to be withdrawn automatically.

Whether you have only a few loans or sixteen like we currently do, setting up automatic minimum payment withdrawals simplifies things and greatly reduces any desire to unnecessarily consolidate.  An added benefit is that a few lenders offered us a 0.25% decrease in interest rate for signing up for automatic withdrawal.

3) Extend loan terms beyond standard repayment plan

It sounds counter-intuitive at first. Why would someone hoping to dig their way out of debt as quickly as possible be interested in extending the term of any loan? By extending the loan repayment terms on as many of our federal loans as possible, we were able to decrease the minimum payment required on our loans each month. This resulted in two benefits: decreasing our overall minimum payments allows us to make the maximum payment possible on the single loan that we’re focused on paying off and a second, not insignificant side benefit is that it also directly decreases the amount of money we have to spend in a given month in the event that our finances were tight for a period of time for one reason or another.

4) Refinance loans to lower interest rates

With the bulk of our student loan debt coming in the form of graduate school federal loans, the interest rates varied from 6.8 to as high as 8.5%. Fortunately, we were able to refinance a number of these loans with another lender for rates between 2.8-3.2%. By decreasing our interest rates on each loan by at least 3.6% (from a minimum of 6.8% to a maximum of 3.2%), we were able to save over $300 per month for every $100,000 financed on interest alone! Refinancing these loans came with some level of risk though, as we refinanced with variable rate loans, which we’ll discuss further in the near future.

5) Organize and prioritize loan repayment order

The two primary strategies for accelerating loan repayment are either to prioritize loans by their balance from smallest to largest or by interest rate from largest to smallest. The former being commonly referred to as the debt snowball and the latter the debt avalanche. Using either strategy, by focusing accelerated payments on a single debt until it is fully paid off, the amount previously being dedicated to that loan can then be rolled over to the next. Eventually this process has a ‘snowball’ or ‘avalanche’ effect as more and more money can be dedicated to a single loan as more and more are paid off.

While there have been many discussions in our home concerning which approach is better, we’re convinced that prioritizing by interest rate is best for us. That’s not to say that the debt snowball doesn’t have its advantages, especially if one is really strapped for cash month to month or is concerned about staying motivated. However, when considering all options, it makes the most financial sense for us to prioritize and pay down the highest interest loan first.

Progress to date

Following this approach since our peak debt of over $521,000 in early 2014, we’ve paid down our principle balance by over $130,000 as of December 2016. We have a long road to go, but we’re getting there. Payment by payment. Month by month. We’re getting there.

11 thoughts on “How we’re paying off over $500,000 of student loan debt

  1. Pingback: Think Save Retire
  2. Wow, $500k in loans?! I’m assuming that one of you is a doctor to justify that sort of investment?Dentists do OK in Australia but I wouldn’t say that a dentist’s income justified a 50% share of that sort of debt.

    Well done on paying the loans down so far, but how long would you say you have to go? If it takes you 8 years to pay them off (and you are putting so much of your I come into them to even achieve that timeframe) it doesn’t seem to stack up!

    1. Hi there InsiderAccountant. If by doctor, you mean physician, the answer is no. I have a Ph.D in engineering and my wife is a dentist. We describe our situation a bit more thoroughly in other posts, but we amassed that level of debt after 16 years of college and graduate school between the two of us. A rough estimate is that ~75% of this balance is from financing her dental school education. We haven’t gotten into the details of this cost yet (we will), but it boils down to the simple fact that tuition for private dental school is the U.S. is expensive.

      Now, we obviously could have avoided this level of debt by changing one of a few life choices, but we didn’t. And as odd as it may seem, we don’t regret it either.

      While we’ve only paid down our loans by $130k in the last three years, we’ve improved our net worth by $340k in the same timeframe. So, it will likely take us ~8 years total (five years from now) to pay our loans off, but that will be because we also made it a priority to focus on investment over the course of those 8 years as well (more on this later too).

      Since we started our climb out of debt in Feb. 2014, we’ve dedicated over 70% of our take-home pay to improving our net worth by either investing/saving or debt payments. I’ll leave it up to the reader to decide whether the income/career justifies the level of debt, but we’re optimistic we’ll be ok.

      Thank you kindly for stopping by and leaving us a note.

  3. Good luck on paying down those loans. Sounds like you have a great plan and the fact that you have paid down 130k already that is quite an accomplishment. My wife and I have two doctorates with the bulk of our student loan debt (240k) hers. Just wished we made a larger income. Buen suerte!

  4. Thanks Jason. Best of luck to you guys. I’ll stop by and check out your story and progress.

    1. Thanks Erik. It sure would be miserable to have anything other than a positive attitude. 🙂

      I appreciate you stopping by!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *